Image credit: Surrey
County Council
This is my detailed response to a local government
consultation “West Surrey Council Corporate Strategy Engagement,” to be found
here: [[1]].
This document gives supplementary information to my answer to the on-line questionnaire.
I am responding in my personal capacity as a resident of
Waverley borough. Though I should make clear that I am also campaign manager
for the local branch (Godalming and Ash) of Reform UK.
I have to say at the outset that I have concerns, at many
different levels, with all that has been and is going on in government, and the
local government re-organization in particular. And that the case I will make
is a complex, wide-ranging one, which requires quotes from, and links to, documentary
evidence. That explains the length of this response – over 6,000 words!
The consultation
The consultation is a multiple-choice questionnaire. There
are opportunities to give free-text answers to some questions, but these are
limited both in number and in answer length. So, it is not possible to include
in the questionnaire the level of comments I feel I need to. I therefore
provide this in document form.
I understand that the email address devolutionandlgr@surreycc.gov.uk
has been set up to receive questionnaires which have been completed on-line. And
that this address can also be used to send supplementary information. I will
copy this document to that e-mail.
Background
It is important to be clear about the background against which
this consultation is taking place. Particularly as the residents of West Surrey,
most of all in Waverley and Guildford boroughs – within which our constituency
lies – are in a uniquely disadvantaged position in this matter. Moreover, our
situation in Surrey may well be of interest to those in other counties.
Local government re-organization
A local government re-organization is being imposed in
Surrey by the Labour government. This will abolish Surrey County Council (SCC) and
six borough councils (Waverley, Guildford, Surrey Heath, Woking, Runnymede and
Spelthorne), and replace them with a new West Surrey Council. Councillors for West
Surrey were elected in May 2026, but the council does not take on its powers
until April 2027.
Meanwhile, existing councillors on Surrey County Council
have remained and remain in power, even though they have had no democratic
mandate since May 2025, at which time the scheduled elections were cancelled.
Yet they have continued to impose policies they have been pursuing since 2021,
like proliferating 20mph speed limits (such as recently in Walton on Thames).
The re-organization is being passed off as “devolution,” but
it is nothing of the sort. Under the old system, residents in what is becoming
West Surrey were represented by 81 SCC councillors and 242 borough councillors,
a total of 323. Whereas West Surrey will have just 162 councillors. This is not
bringing local government closer to home, but centralizing power, and making it
more remote, less accessible and less accountable.
And future plans for a Mayor of Surrey will centralize power
still further. Particularly because it seems very unclear how West Surrey
councillors can resist a mayoral agenda, when that agenda clashes with the
needs and desires of the local people who elected them. For example, I have
seen a statement that a unitary council will not be able to override a mayor’s
transport policy.
Surrey has both urban, London-leaning parts, and rural and suburban
parts. And the transport needs of people in the two are completely different.
In such an area, to install a mayor with the power to impose one transport policy
on the whole area is a recipe for disaster. As the people of outer London have
found out the hard way. Yet the Tories, and the Lib Dem leader of East Surrey,
have actively welcomed the plan: [[2]].
I am concerned that both these parties want to subject us to what I have (not
jokingly) called “ULEZ in Puttenham and Peaslake.”
Council debts
A further major factor is that irresponsible financial
behaviour from three of the borough councils in the area which will form West
Surrey has left them, and so West Surrey itself, in a position of very
substantial debt.
Woking’s debt, as of early 2026, was £2.2 billion, or
around £20,000 per resident. Discussions are still going on over who will ultimately
pay for this. Spelthorne’s debt reached £1 billion in early 2025, but is
currently being re-structured. Runnymede’s is about £600 million. Surrey Heath
also seems to have rapidly rising debt (I have seen a figure of £170 million),
and a projected annual operating shortfall of about £8 million. Guildford’s
debt reached £300 million in 2023, but it has improved matters since. Waverley’s
total debt of £140 million (about £1,100 per resident) is middling by Surrey
standards.
Meanwhile, Surrey County Council’s own debt level surged
by almost 50% in a year, to nearly £1.1 billion for 2024/5: [[3]].
And the BBC reports that West Surrey faces a “very challenging” financial
position: [[4]].
2025 consultation
There was a consultation, held in the summer of 2025,
on the re-organization proposals. However, this was not satisfactory from the
point of view of residents of the better-run boroughs in what is now becoming
West Surrey. Particularly since no plan was offered to retain the existing
structure until the debt issues had been resolved.
Two proposals were offered, one for a division of Surrey
into two unitary councils, the other into three. Neither of these proposals was
exactly attractive, though the three-unitary was less bad for the people in our
area. But it was clear that, regardless of the merits, the two-unitary
proposal, strongly supported by the Tories who were at the time in control of
SCC, was always going to win.
Status of the re-organization
In September 2026, the re-organization plans in several
counties were put on hold [[5]]
due to new legal advice. But Surrey was not included in this process. So, the amalgamation
into West Surrey and East Surrey is still going ahead, even though there are significant
financial issues still unresolved. All this in the context of a funding model
for local government, which even central government concedes is broken.
All these outstanding issues put Waverley and Guildford
residents, in particular, in a uniquely bad position with regard to the local
government re-organization, and threaten to trap us in a “worst of all possible
worlds” situation.
The West Surrey consultation
Before asking anything about people’s opinions, the
consultation sets out the “draft ambitions” for the new West Surrey Council. In
essence, these are the ideas by which those who expect to be in charge of West
Surrey want to guide their policies. They are split into four “themes.” I
will reproduce those here.
Theme 1: A thriving and sustainable West Surrey
We want West Surrey to be a great place to live, now and in
the future. We want people to feel proud of their local area, connected to
their community, and able to help shape where they live. We want to protect our
environment and green spaces and be ready for the impacts of climate change.
Theme 2: A supportive West Surrey
We want West Surrey to be a place where everyone can live
well. This means having access to health and care support and the housing
people need to live happy, healthy and independent lives.
Theme 3: A prosperous West Surrey
We want West Surrey to be a place with good jobs, successful
businesses and opportunities for everyone. We want people and communities to
benefit from a strong local economy.
Theme 4: A trusted and well-run council
We want people to trust their council. This means providing
reliable services, spending public money wisely, listening to residents and
making good decisions for local communities.
The other councils’ Corporate Strategies
Corporate strategies are nothing new. Surrey County Council,
Waverley and Guildford Borough Councils, and Godalming Town Council all have
them already. It is instructive to take a look at key extracts from these
documents.
But, tucked away in the background behind all these strategy
plans, is a document, first published in 2018, called the Community Vision for
Surrey in 2030 [[6]].
Despite its age, this document is still being maintained, having last been
modified in August 2026. So, this vision must still be being sought; at least
by the Tories, who were in control of SCC from 2018 up to May 2026. I shall
therefore begin with the vision document.
Community Vision for Surrey in 2030
“By 2030 we want Surrey to be a uniquely special place where
everyone has a great start to life, people live healthy and fulfilling lives,
are enabled to achieve their full potential and contribute to their community,
and no one is left behind.
Our ambitions for people are:
·
Children and young people are safe and feel safe
and confident.
·
Everyone benefits from education, skills and
employment opportunities that help them succeed in life.
·
Everyone lives healthy, active and fulfilling
lives, and makes good choices about their wellbeing.
·
Everyone gets the health and social care support
and information they need at the right time and place.
·
Communities are welcoming and supportive,
especially of those most in need, and people feel able to contribute to
community life.
We want our county’s economy to be strong, vibrant and
successful and Surrey to be a great place to live, work and learn. A place that
capitalises on its location and natural assets, and where communities feel
supported and people are able to support each other.
Our ambitions for our place are:
·
Residents live in clean, safe and green
communities, where people and organisations embrace their environmental
responsibilities.
·
Journeys across the county are easier, more
predictable and safer.
·
Everyone has a place they can call home, with
appropriate housing for all.
·
Businesses in Surrey thrive.
·
Well connected communities, with effective
infrastructure, that grow sustainably.”
Surrey County Council [[7]]
(Although the link says 2021 to 2026, the document itself
addresses the period 2023 to 2028.)
“We have a key role to play in improving the quality of life
for residents of Surrey, enhancing the infrastructure for business and
protecting the natural environment for generations to come.
To fulfil that role, we are committed to a very clear set of
priorities;
·
Growing a sustainable economy so everyone can
benefit,
·
tackling health inequality,
·
enabling a greener future,
·
empowered and thriving communities.
Underpinning all our work is our overarching ambition to
help everyone in Surrey benefit from all the opportunities on offer in our
county, and to ensure that no one is left behind. Now, and in the future.
Helping those who need us most, and improving quality of
life for everyone.”
Guildford Borough Council [[8]]
“A Greener, Fairer, Thriving Guildford sets out our
priorities as a council for the next ten years, and how we plan to make
Guildford borough a thriving place to live, work and do business.
Over the ten next years, we’re focusing on five key
priorities for our activities as a council. These are:
·
a more sustainable borough – we’re committed to
becoming a more socially and environmentally responsible borough
·
a more prosperous borough - building on
Guildford borough’s strong local economy to attract inward investment
·
a more inclusive borough - a welcoming borough
where people of diverse identities feel valued, respected, included, supported,
and represented
·
decent and affordable homes - we will use the
powers and means available to us to ensure that local people have access to
decent homes that they can afford
·
a resilient and well-managed council – we’re
committed to public service, we exist to serve our residents, businesses, and
visitors.”
Waverley Borough Council [[9]]
“Our vision as a council is to make Waverley a thriving and
inclusive place to live, work, and do business.
To do this, over the next four years, we will focus on five
key priorities for our activities as a council:
1.
A more sustainable borough
2.
A more prosperous borough
3.
A more inclusive borough
4.
Decent and affordable homes
5.
A resilient and well-managed council.”
Godalming Town Council
Godalming Town Council’s corporate strategy is here: [[10]].
And I’ve already written, excoriatingly, about it: [[11]].
It is worth noting that, unlike SCC before May 2026, the town council is Lib
Dem controlled, with significant Green participation and only two Tories. And
the composition has been similar since 2019. Before then, the Tories had
monopolized the council.
The strategy states that Godalming Town Council will, among
much else:
·
Support and promote Equality, Diversity and
Inclusion.
·
Provide support, grants and promotion for local
businesses that are actively working towards becoming carbon neutral.
·
Promote at least 10% Biodiversity Net Gain on
private land and ensure it on land that we own.
·
Support measures to improve air quality and
water quality across the Godalming Town Council area.
·
Ensure that Godalming Town Council is carbon
neutral across Scope 1 and 2 by 2025 and across all other areas of its own
operations by 2030.
·
Ensure net zero scope 3 emissions by 2030.
·
Lobby for and, wherever possible, deliver
infrastructure for electric vehicles ahead of 2030.
·
Promote an understanding of the climate and
ecological crisis amongst our community and work together on strategies for
reduction of individual carbon footprint.
·
Support divestment in fossil fuels and oppose
development of new sources for fossil fuels through ‘fracking,’ ‘acidisation,’
drilling and other unsustainable approaches.
·
Strive to be a net exporter of renewable energy
to the grid by 2030.
·
Promote the concept of Godalming becoming a
zero-waste town by encouraging repair, reuse, and re-fashioning in addition to
re-cycling an increasingly wide range of items, diminishing the quantity of
residual waste generated across the town.
·
Promote opportunities for a balanced, pedestrian
and cycle-friendly, sustainable and affordable public transport system.
·
Continue to lobby for the implementation of a
20mph speed limit for the Godalming Town Council area and take action to
promote active and sustainable travel.
Common Themes
It is easy to see similarities between different councils’
corporate strategies. Waverley’s, for example, is a paraphrase of Guildford’s. There
are also words or phrases that occur multiple times. For example: “community”
or “communities,” “inclusive,” “safe,” “diverse” or “diversity,” “equality” or
“inequality,” “resilient,” “sustainable,” “protect,” “environment,” “green” or
“greener,” “climate,” “health” or “healthy,” “no-one left behind.”
These suggest that not only the words, but also the ideas
behind them, may well have had a common origin. All the corporate strategies
contain elements, at least, of what I call “UN-speak.” So, I can give you a
good candidate for the common origin of these words and ideas. And it will explain
why the “community vision for Surrey,” from 2018, focuses on 2030.
The United Nations’ “Sustainable Development Goals”
This agenda was agreed on all our behalves by David Cameron,
as I recall without any public debate, at the UN in September 2015. It is also
known as the “2030 Agenda for Sustainable Development.” It can be found here: [[12]].
The UK government says it “provides an ambitious, globally-agreed, shared
blueprint for the world we want to see by 2030.” [[13]].
I gave my views on that agenda earlier this year, here: [[14]].
They are not positive. Indeed, I called that vision “nothing less than a
blueprint for the complete destruction of human civilization as we know it
today, and for tyranny by a self-appointed global ruling class over every human
being alive.” And I used the 2021-2 famine in Sri Lanka as evidence that
so-called “sustainable development” is, in reality, not sustainable.
Here are some quotes from the 2030 agenda, which may help
persuade you that it is a big part, at least, of the common origin of the
various “corporate strategies.”
Preamble. “As we embark on this collective journey,
we pledge that no one will be left behind.”
People. “We are determined… to ensure that all human
beings can fulfil their potential in dignity and equality and in a healthy
environment.”
§9.
“We envisage a world in which…” “…consumption and production patterns and use
of all natural resources – from air to land, from rivers, lakes and aquifers to
oceans and seas – are sustainable.” “…sustainable development, including
sustained and inclusive economic growth…” and “environmental protection.” “In
which development and the application of technology are climate-sensitive,
respect biodiversity and are resilient.” “In which humanity lives in harmony
with nature and in which wildlife and other living species are protected.”
§27.
Sustained, inclusive and sustainable economic growth… will only be possible if
wealth is shared and income inequality is addressed.”
§34.
“We recognize that sustainable urban development and management are crucial to
the quality of life of our people. We will work with local authorities to renew
and plan our cities and human settlements so as to foster community cohesion
and personal security…” “The reduction and recycling of waste and the more
efficient use of water and energy.”
Goal 3. “Ensure healthy lives and promote well-being
for all at all ages.”
Goal 3.9. “Substantially reduce… deaths and illnesses
from… air, water and soil pollution.”
Goal 11. “Make cities and human settlements
inclusive, safe, resilient and sustainable.”
Goal 11.1. “Ensure access for all to adequate, safe
and affordable housing…”
Goal 11.2. “Provide access to safe, affordable,
accessible and sustainable transport systems for all, improving road safety,
notably by expanding public transport.”
Goal 11.7. “By 2030, provide universal access to
safe, green and public spaces, in particular for… older persons and persons
with disabilities.”
Goal 13.2. “Integrate climate change measures into
national policies, strategies and planning.”
I think it is fair to say that the thinking behind this
agenda, if not always the exact words, has significantly influenced all four of
the councils’ strategies, from 2018 up to the present.
My thoughts on the agenda
This is what successive governments, Tory and Labour, have presented
as “the world we want to see by 2030.” And there is a hard “do by” date on it.
2030 is only a little over three years away. That explains why the proponents
of the agenda seem to be in such a hurry.
When I first read the agenda, back in about 2017, I thought
of it as no more than an earnest, good-sounding wish-list. It was not in my
worst dreams that they would actually try to do all this to us. Nor that their
2030 target was hard and inflexible. Yet, that is where we now are.
But wait a moment… I thought government was supposed to serve
the people? To work for us, for our benefit, and with our consent? Why, then,
is it doing all this crap to us?
Some of my reasons for opposing the agenda are political. I do
not respect the UN or its fellow travellers, and here is why: [[15]].
Moreover, being an individualist, I want maximum freedom for everyone who
respects the equal rights and freedoms of their fellow human beings. I do not
wish to go on any “collective journey” with anyone whose desired destination is
incompatible with mine. And to allow an undemocratic, unaccountable
organization like the UN (or the EU) to influence, let alone to set, policies
in a supposed “democracy,” is a travesty. So, I want nothing to do with the
“sustainable development goals,” or any part of them, or anyone that parrots the
UN-speak in which they are written.
Other reasons are evidential. Having been trained as a
mathematician, I don’t draw conclusions without examining evidence and thinking
logically. I have enough understanding of science, history, ethics and politics
to know, without doubt, that the “evidence” for the UN’s agendas doesn’t
support the lies, scares, hype and gaslighting, to which we are subjected by
politicians, activists, media, “experts” and many others that stand to gain
from those agendas. I know beyond doubt, for example, that there is no “climate
crisis” or “nature crisis,” and here’s why: [[16]].
And I know beyond doubt that there has been serious political interference by the
UK government, over many years, in the science of air pollution: [[17]].
Moreover, I can read the entrails well enough to see that,
far from being better off as a result of the adoption of these agendas, people
are worse off. Far from “wealth being shared” and “inequality being addressed,”
today the politically rich are getting richer, and we the politically poor are
getting poorer: [[18]].
I have more reasons too; ethical ones. I condemn the
arrogance and dishonesty of those that want to force me in a direction I and
many others do not want, yet have never allowed our opposition to be heard. And
I resent the violations of rights and freedoms that successive governments of
all parties have done, to me and others, in the name of political agendas I am
utterly opposed to. Government, at all levels, ought to serve people, not to oppress
us.
West Surrey
To return, full circle, to the West Surrey corporate
strategy and consultation questionnaire.
Theme 1: A thriving and sustainable West Surrey
All the strategies use the word “sustainable” many times.
But only one says what they mean by it: “more socially and environmentally
responsible.” That is very different from what I mean by “sustainable,” which
is “able to endure into the future.” What I have experienced is that in recent
decades, policies that aim to make us “socially and environmentally
responsible” have actually made us far poorer. So, this is not a word I am at
all comfortable to see in any strategy. If government, at any level, puts some
ill-defined “sustainability” above the interests and prosperity of the people
it is supposed to serve, it is failing in its job.
“We want people to feel… connected to their community.” The
authors of the questionnaire seem to sense that people have begun to feel
disconnected from those around them, both at local level and on a wider scale.
And they are right. People living under a political system that treats them badly
will always, over time, become alienated from it. And we have been treated
badly by governments of all parties for decades now.
“We want people to feel… able to help shape where they
live.” Here is another concern along similar lines. All the mainstream political
parties offer the same old, same old mealy-mouthed guff. Like (I’ll repeat the
list): “community” or “communities,” “inclusive,” “safe,” “diverse” or
“diversity,” “equality” or “inequality,” “resilient,” “sustainable,” “protect,”
“environment,” “green” or “greener,” “climate,” “health” or “healthy,” “no-one left
behind.” Further, all of them support policies that are costly vanity projects,
or cause inconvenience or restrictions on our freedoms. The Guildford to Godalming
Greenway, and the Farncombe street “improvements,” for example. And some are so
extremist, that they want to abandon fossil fuels, which would destroy our
Western civilization.
Those of us who don’t believe any of this greenwash, and
even more those who, like me, know that it isn’t based on any objective evidence,
feel disempowered in the face of a juggernaut, supported by all the mainstream
political parties both nationally and locally, that relentlessly grinds away at
our rights and freedoms. You should not be surprised that Reform UK, the one
party which actually values people over politics and common sense over virtue
signalling, has been growing in strength.
“We want to protect our environment and green spaces.” This is
self-contradictory. Green spaces – like parks, hills, footpaths, lake shores –
are valuable to human beings. So, protecting them (for example from
development) is valuable. But “protect our environment” has taken on an almost
opposite meaning. See what I said above about being “socially and
environmentally responsible.” For me, the environment that must be protected is
the environment for human beings. And green mumbo-jumbo like
“biodiversity net gain” should never take precedence over it. Besides which,
local government exists to serve those who pay for it – and wildlife don’t pay
council taxes.
“We want to… be ready for the impacts of climate change.”
Strangely, this represents a degree of walk-back compared with earlier extreme
green visions, such as “stopping and reversing climate change.” I am a little
bit encouraged by this walk-back, as it seems like a baby step towards admitting
that “nett zero” was never going to solve anything, and that the eye-watering
costs imposed on us have simply been money down the drain.
Now, it’s true that the climate changes. It always has done,
and it always will, till Earth is no more. And it did so long before the
Industrial Revolution; witness the last Ice Age, the Holocene Climate Optimum,
and the Minoan, Roman and Mediaeval Warm Periods. No doubt, human industrial
activities have had some effect on the climate. But despite rantings by the UN
and politicized “scientists” and “experts,” no-one actually knows how much
impact humans have actually caused. And no-one actually knows whether, in terms
of human flourishing, the impact of a moderate warming (say, 4 or 5oC)
would be positive or negative.
History, though, tells us that humanity has flourished far better
in warmer periods than colder ones. So, I for one am not worried about “the
impacts of climate change.” Bad weather will happen, and we should cope with it
when it happens. And that’s it.
Equality, Diversity and Inclusion (EDI)
The West Surrey Themes do not mention any of these
buzz-words. But the phrase “connected to the community” does suggest that this
matter should be covered under Theme 1. Particularly since the questionnaire asks
about “people with different backgrounds” and “community tensions,” and asks
for the detailed ethnic background of respondees.
East Surrey council has, in recent days, issued a bulletin
on its activities in this area: [[19]].
“A strong, inclusive and resilient East Surrey.” UN-speak is alive and well and
living in East Surrey. And I, for one, don’t approve of EDI, or of any
government that mandates it from local councils.
Now, the concern I expressed above is that many residents of
our area have lost contact with the political system they are forced to live
under. We (for I count myself among them) do not feel included any more.
However, just as concerning is the policy, mandated by
successive governments, called “diversity, equality and inclusion.” To make out
that this is a framework “to promote fair treatment, representation, and full
participation for all people” is to disguise what many people feel about its
effects.
There is a widespread perception that high levels of
immigration encouraged by successive governments are changing the UK’s culture
in ways hostile to native people. In particular, the “equality” ideal has been misused
to move towards a two-tier social structure in the UK, with ethnic natives,
along with other white people, in the lower tier. The killing of Henry Nowak
provided a stark example of this.
A second concern is that the English and British culture,
whose values produced the Enlightenment and the Industrial Revolution, is being
submerged. Our values are drowning in a sea of other cultures, not all of which
are compatible with our own. This is shown up by the more and more contemptuous
treatment of the people by successive governments. As, for example, signing us up
to the UN’s Sustainable Development Goals without public debate, or any
opportunity to object. That is not government for the benefit of the governed!
A third concern, particularly affecting women, is that the greatly
increasing number of Muslims in the UK is more and more spreading a culture,
which assigns to women a much lower status than they have in Western cultures.
Now, I do not in any way condone racism or gender
discrimination. I judge individuals by their actions, rather than by
characteristics outside their control. Otherwise put, what matters isn’t who
you are, but how you behave. That said, to reject people’s cultural concerns by
calling them nasty names like “racist” is unjust and unhelpful.
Theme 2: A supportive West Surrey
Living well “needs access to health and care support… to
live happy, healthy and independent lives.” Well, yes. But when the NHS is overstretched,
and people can’t afford private health services, it isn’t easy even to get a
doctor’s appointment.
There are lots of problems with the NHS, most of which are
national in scope. But the politicization of health care, which started in 1906
and greatly intensified in 1948, was never going to be sustainable (in the true
sense of the word). Anything the state touches eventually turns into excrement.
And we’re needing to shovel the stuff now. There is a need for radical reform,
which goes way beyond anything West Surrey can do unaided.
“Care support,” on the other hand, is a relatively new idea.
It is also something that not everyone needs, at least until they reach old age.
It seems to have been bolted on to the welfare state, without a great amount of
thought about how best to do it, and in particular about how it should be
funded. This is already causing stresses, in that people who have never used
such support are now being expected to pay for it, yet there seems to be no
guarantee that they will get it as and when they need it. Again, this is wider
than West Surrey.
Living well also needs “access to… housing.” There are two
separate housing issues at the local level. One, council housing. This system
has been going since at least 1919 (perhaps 1890). It isn’t a matter in which I
take a great interest, though I note that some London councils have waiting
lists of more than 100 years!
The other is mandatory house building targets. This is a
very serious problem in Waverley, where the Tories had already mandated a very
high target, which Labour promptly doubled. Last year, I responded to a
consultation about the Waverley local plan, with this: [[20]].
I still stand by everything I said there.
The housing target represents a 53% increase in the
population of Waverley from 2023 to 2043. Waverley Borough Council, rightly,
objected to this as unrealistic: [[21]].
This is something which West Surrey council is going to have to fight very hard
on, as it is clear that Waverley, and to a lesser extent Guildford, residents
have been singled out for social engineering on a huge scale; which would
change the character of our entire corner of Surrey, very much for the worse.
You need only look at the movements against more new homes in Tongham, and in neighbouring
Normandy, to see how people feel on this issue.
Transport
I wonder why “transport” was not included in Theme 2? If
where you live is away from town and village centres, you need transport in
order to get to and from them. (As well as anywhere else you need to go).
If walking or cycling are not feasible for you, and public
transport is non-existent or not good enough, then a car is an essential. After
all, the theme does say that people should be able to live independent lives! So,
West Surrey must scrap SCC’s policies of making it expensive and slow to drive
a car in our area. And Godalming Town Council also should scrap its green
virtue-signalling, and let people make their own transport choices. So that
indeed, “journeys across the county are easier, more predictable and safer.”
Theme 3: A prosperous West Surrey
I can’t disagree with anything here. But I will say that for
people like me (I am 73), it will be too little, too late.
Theme 4: A trusted and well-run council
“We want people to trust their council. This means providing
reliable services, spending public money wisely, listening to residents and
making good decisions for local communities.” All these things are necessary. Though
at the end, I would add “and for every individual in them.”
But the ultimate key to getting trust is being honest with
people. That is a lot harder than it sounds. You will need to be open,
transparent, candid and sincere in everything you do and say. You will need to
adhere fully to the Nolan Principles (yes, I’ve written about those, too: [[22]]).
And you will need to work for the interests of everyone in West Surrey. Everyone.
In particular, you will need to fight against impositions
from national government, that are damaging, or threaten to damage, the lives
of people in your area. For example: You will need to fight against nett zero,
anti-car and other bad green policies (it will need a Reform national government
to fix those in full). You will need to fight against EDI, and the culture that
has resulted from it. And you will need to fight, on behalf of the residents of
Waverley and Guildford in particular, against the impossible housing targets.
Specific points on the questionnaire
To the questionnaire itself. I will identify the questions
using text from the question or option, as there are no question numbers on the
electronic version.
Oh, and I’ll add another UN-speak buzzphrase to my list, as
it occurs several times in the questionnaire: “working with partners.”
Making it easier and safer to travel around West Surrey
I feel this option is poorly phrased, because there is a
conflict between making travel easier and the overblown “safety” agenda being forced
on us. The former requires better roads. (Even if what you want is more buses,
they have to travel on roads!) The latter has been used to bring in draconian
speed limits, narrow our roads and install obstructions on them.
I am utterly opposed to 20mph speed limits and to narrowing
of, or obstructions on, the roads. In particular, safety benefits of 20mph
versus 30mph are not proven. See this study, from 2018: [[23]].
It says, of 20mph limits: “Based on the evidence available to date, this study
has found no significant change in collisions and casualties, in the short
term.” As far as I know, more recent studies have not found any objective
safety benefits either.
I am also aware that these policies are being driven by a UN
WHO scheme called “Vision Zero.” For an undemocratic, unaccountable
organization like the WHO to be pushing policies that seriously affect the
everyday lives of people in Surrey or anywhere else, makes a complete mockery
of any pretence of democracy.
I feel that I belong in my local area
I have lived in Godalming for 40 years, yet since 2019 in
particular, I have found the local political atmosphere malodorous and
unpleasant. This is why I cannot respond higher than “Neither agree nor
disagree.” (My views on national politics are even more damning).
People from different backgrounds get on well in my local area
The immigrants we have here in Godalming are generally good
people. They do useful jobs, like driving taxis and running convenience stores,
and I certainly don’t have any problems with them. I only wish it were like
that in the big cities.
My local town or village centre is easy to get around if you have
accessibility needs
Godalming and Farncombe town centres are both fairly flat. Their
catchment areas are not. The problem is not getting around the centres, but
getting to and, particularly, back from them. This makes my car an essential to
me.
I believe I can personally influence decisions affecting my local area
Definitely disagree. That is one reason why I felt a need to
get involved with Reform UK, though my main focus has been more on national and
global issues. And for my sins, I have ended up as the local campaign manager.
More general thoughts on the questionnaire process
Several questions, for example under “Concerns and
priorities for the first year,” ask you to pick one or more from a long list of
wishes. In many cases, I found it difficult to say Yes to even one of the
options, and there were no opportunities to record my opposition to those of
which I disapprove. In my opinion, this biases the whole process towards the views
of those who agree with many of the offered selections, and against those who
agree with only a few.
Would it not have been better, in each case, to offer five
choices: Strongly Agree, Agree, Neutral, Disagree, Strongly Disagree? That
would both have given opportunities for dissenters to express their views, and made
it possible to identify what I call “policy-bots,” activists that use such
questionnaires to seek to push as many of the policies as they can.
This is not the first time I have seen this problem. The
initial engagement on Farncombe Local Streets “improvements” not only was biased
towards anti-car sentiments by putting them at the top of the list, but also
permitted multiple votes.
Electoral Commission standards
I have looked for, but failed to find, Electoral Commission
standards on questionnaires such as this one. I plan to raise that issue with
them.
However, these seem to be the standards they would apply to
the wording of a local referendum [[24]]:
“A referendum question should present the options clearly,
simply and neutrally.
It should be:
·
easy to understand
·
to the point
·
unambiguous
It should avoid:
·
encouraging voters to consider one response more
favourably than another
·
misleading voters”
In conclusion
In my view, the function of government should not be to implement political agendas or ideologies, or to advantage or disadvantage particular groups of people at the expense of others. It should be to provide an environment, in which everyone can live their own lives as suits them best. That is, an environment of peace, tranquillity, objective justice, and the upholding of rights and freedoms for all those who respect others’ equal rights and freedoms. Beyond that, government should get out of the way.
[[6]] https://www.surreycc.gov.uk/council-and-democracy/finance-and-performance/vision-strategy-and-performance/community-vision-for-surrey-in-2030
[[7]] https://www.surreycc.gov.uk/council-and-democracy/finance-and-performance/vision-strategy-and-performance/2021-to-2026
[[9]] https://www.waverley.gov.uk/about-waverley-borough-council/strategies/corporate-strategy-2024-2028
[[10]] https://godalming-tc.gov.uk/wp-content/uploads/2023/11/Corporate-Plan-2023-27-2-November-2023.pdf
[[13]] https://www.gov.uk/government/topical-events/uk-voluntary-national-review-of-progress-towards-the-sustainable-development-goals
[[19]] https://www.surreycc.gov.uk/community/news/press-releases/2026/building-a-strong,-inclusive-and-resilient-east-surrey
[[20]] https://libertarianism.uk/2025/11/29/waverley-local-plan-issues-and-options-consultation-response/
